House of the Dragon Season 3 Review: A Great Battle, A Crowded War

House of the Dragon's third season finally cashes the check Season 2 wrote, a real war with stakes that land, even if the show still doesn't know what to do with half the people fighting it. I say that as someone who stopped rooting for anyone in this franchise a long time ago, somewhere back in the original Game of Thrones, after watching enough people I'd started to care about get cut down for no real reason. By the time House of the Dragon came along, I'd already given up trying to pick a side before the show even asked me to, and two more seasons of Targaryens turning on their own family over a chair made of swords only confirmed it. So when Rhaenyra (Emma D'Arcy) and Alicent (Olivia Cooke) ended up facing off across what started out as a childhood friendship, I watched it the way I watch most of this franchise now, without a side, just curious how bad it gets. Season 3 premieres June 21 on HBO and HBO Max, and HBO gave critics the first four episodes ahead of time, which is what this review covers.

House of the Dragon Season 3

Season 3 finally delivers the spectacle Season 2 owed us, and the Gullet is everything it needed to be. But spread across this many characters and storylines, not every thread gets the room to actually land, and the season is at its best when it slows down enough to let people just talk to each other.

Pros

• Battle of the Gullet delivers real scale
• Episode 3 is the season's best
• Daemon and Rhaenyra's chemistry still excels

Cons

• Too many characters competing for depth
• Subplots feel thinner than the battles
• Deaths pile up without enough fallout

Where things left off

Quick reset before getting into it, since some of this is easy to lose track of. Season 2 ended with Team Black and Team Green both fully mobilising for the war that had been building since Viserys died, and not exactly in clean ways. Alicent quietly offered Rhaenyra a path into King's Landing, but that plan got complicated fast once it turned out Larys Strong had already smuggled a badly burned Aegon out of the city behind her back. Daemon spent most of that season hallucinating his way through Harrenhal before a vision involving the White Walkers and the old Song of Ice and Fire prophecy convinced him to drop his own claim to the throne and hand his army to Rhaenyra instead, right as Team Black picked up three new dragonriders of its own. By the time the credits rolled, Otto Hightower had vanished into captivity somewhere, and the Triarchy fleet was already sailing toward Corlys's blockade. That's where Season 3 picks up, after a production stretch that included a shorter episode order than planned and George R.R. Martin publicly sniping at the show's direction. None of that friction shows up on screen, which says something in itself.

Season 2 tested my detachment differently. It felt slow and unfinished because the whole season built toward the Battle of the Gullet and then ended right before it actually happened. I kept watching mostly on the promise that the battle was coming. It didn't, not in Season 2 anyway.

Season 3 opens with it instead, and it's the first real sign in two seasons that the show remembers it owes the audience something for waiting this long.

The Gullet earns the hype, and it's chaos by design

This was sold as the most ambitious battle the show has attempted, and for once, that's not just marketing talk. Director Loni Peristere keeps it legible even at full chaos, which is the real achievement here. Corlys (Steve Toussaint) is running the Velaryon fleet, Lohar's Triarchy ships are coming the other way, and dragons are dropping into the middle of it from both sides. Compared to Rook's Rest last season, where Aemond and Vhagar did most of the damage in one terrifying pass, this is chaos in every direction at once: sea, sky, ships, dragons, all happening at the same time, and the practical and VFX work blend well enough that at a few points I genuinely couldn't tell what I was looking at.

Showrunner Ryan Condal has called this one a major crossing of the Rubicon for the show, and it plays like it. He's said the Corlys and Lohar matchup specifically comes from real history between them; the two have apparently been circling each other for two decades, and Lohar's whole motivation walking into this fight is just to get at the Sea Snake and ruin him. Condal pointed to Wrath of Khan as a reference for the tone he wanted, and that tracks; there's an actual grudge running underneath all the larger-scale carnage, not just two armies colliding because the plot needed a war.

He's also talked about the dragons themselves as more like nuclear weapons than military assets, a Cold War stand-off where their full use ends badly for everyone involved. That's the part of the battle that actually got to me, more than the scale of it. Nobody here has the comfort of an advantage, and you can feel it in how long the show stays with the wreckage instead of cutting away.

I Miss the Council Table

Something's been nagging at me after watching these action-packed episodes. What I actually miss is something the original Game of Thrones did for years: Tyrion and Varys working an angle in the same room, Tywin shutting an entire plan down with one line, a small council that functioned as a place where decisions got made and unmade before anyone unsheathed a sword. That's the political texture I keep waiting for House of the Dragon to lean back into.

House of the Dragon doesn't always build that foundation first anymore. Why are other lords actually choosing Team Black or Team Green over just staying out of it? What's the personal cost to any of them outside the Targaryen family itself? The Gullet is a great battle on its own terms, but I keep wondering if it feels as massive as it does, partly because the politics around it haven't laid enough groundwork.

Some of that thinning out might just be how the show is built. Fire & Blood reads more like a history book than a novel, so adapting it means picking which stretches get the scene-by-scene treatment and which get compressed or skipped. It looks like the writers are choosing momentum over build-up this season. Some of the Rhaenyra-Alicent tension that carried over from last season has been pushed to the background in favour of faster plotting.

House of the Dragon doesn't always build that slow foundation first anymore. Why are other lords choosing Team Black or Team Green over just staying out of it? What's the personal cost to any of them outside the Targaryen family itself? The Gullet is a great battle on its own terms, but I keep wondering if it feels as massive as it does, partly because the politics around it haven't laid enough groundwork.

Episode 3 is the show at its best

Written by Sara Hess, this episode follows Rhaenyra trying to rule, council politics and difficult decisions taking over the hour. I love the dragons; they're a genuine reason I keep watching this show, but this episode is proof the writing can hold me without them. It even sneaks in a scene of straight class commentary, which the show almost never makes time for. It's the strongest episode of the four for exactly that reason, and it's the version of this show I wish we got more often. Rhaenyra spends the hour learning how hard ruling is, and D'Arcy finally gets to play her scared and uncertain, which the battles never give her room for.

The Cast Is Carrying This

The first half of this season leans hard on a few pairings to carry it, and most of them land. Daemon and Rhaenyra are circling the same problems all season from completely different angles. He's always looking for the opening in a situation. She's stuck staring at what it'll cost her to take it. Matt Smith and Emma D'Arcy play that gap well enough that it might be the best chemistry the show's had between any two characters. The pull between Rhaenyra and Alicent hasn't gone anywhere either. Cooke and D'Arcy still carry an old friendship and a live rivalry in the same scene, sometimes in the same line, even with an ocean and a war between their characters now.

James Norton's Ormund Hightower earns his spot too. No two seasons of baggage behind him, so he just gets to be a threat instead of a character everyone's already decided how to feel about.

Tom Glynn-Carney is quietly doing some of the best work in the cast as Aegon, even stuck hiding out after last season's deal. There's more going on behind his eyes than the show's given him credit for so far.

Aemond's barely around either, odd given how big Season 2 made him. The marketing and Ewan Mitchell's own interviews have been promising a much bigger, stranger arc for him once he leaves King's Landing for Harrenhal, so this might just be the quiet before that.

Too many characters, not enough time

My actual issue with the show isn't that it's dark; I expect that going in. It's that there are too many characters now for most of them to get real development. The show seems to know it too. That's probably why the scenes that do slow down, Aegon's handful this stretch, Episode 3's hour with Rhaenyra, work as well as they do. The rest of the season piles on deaths, dragon battles, and major political moves without earning the same weight, mostly because I'm not as invested in everyone it's happening to as the show wants me to be. Nobody sits with the fallout either. Something huge happens, and the show has already moved on before it can process what that loss costs the people left behind.

I'd take more time with fewer people to cover this much ground this fast. The Gullet proved the spectacle works. I'm still looking for the thematic weight beneath it all, and four episodes in, I'm coming up a little short.

Four episodes in, the show has the scale and a handful of performances strong enough to make me want to see where the rest of this goes. What I want now is for the back half to give that same room to the people fighting this war who aren't named Rhaenyra or Alicent. The Gullet already proved the show can stage a battle. Whether the rest of the season remembers everyone who was standing in it is the part I'm still not sure about.

Written by

Share

Copied