John Carpenter has named a backup director for the Escape From New York remake, leaving Zack Snyder’s involvement unclear.
On the Dropping Names With Brent And Jonny podcast, first written up by The A.V. Club, Carpenter said Robert Rodriguez has a new story he wants to tell. Carpenter is taking a wait-and-see approach to whether Snyder will direct.
Snyder was attached to write and direct when the remake was announced in June 2026. He confirmed his involvement in September. CBR reports that Snyder’s version would be set in 1997, keeping the retro-futuristic setting of Carpenter’s 1981 original.
On the podcast, co-host Jonathan Frakes exclaimed, “Zack Snyder—he’s on fire!” Carpenter replied:
He’s not anymore, but he’s trying to get back. He’s a nice man. I liked him.
John Carpenter, director of the original Escape From New York
ComicBook.com read the reply as meaning Snyder was off the remake but could return. A listener quoted by the site says the “trying to get back” remark was about Snyder’s career, not the film. World of Reel notes that some outlets read the comment as meaning Snyder was off the project, while others think Carpenter misspoke.
The A.V. Club suggested Carpenter could have meant the reception to The Last Photograph at the Toronto International Film Festival in September. He may also have meant the Rebel Moon sequels, which appear to have stalled at Netflix.
Carpenter was more direct about Rodriguez: “We have a backup: Robert Rodriguez [has] a new story he wants to do. So, we’ll see.” ComicBook.com reports Carpenter has signed off on Rodriguez’s idea and script.
Before Snyder, the remake had been linked to Radio Silence, Leigh Whannell, Brett Ratner, Len Wiseman, Breck Eisner, and Neil Cross. World of Reel reports the remake is still aiming to start production in 2027. The project has no confirmed release date.
CBR reports that Snyder teased an actor in mind for Snake Plissken, the role Kurt Russell played in the original, but no casting has been confirmed. Whoever ends up directing, Carpenter still intends to compose the score: “I demanded to be the composer.”


















